It was a glorious day out, and great company, but "The Garfish" let me down with their food.
Here is my recent review:
More info at
Eatabilty site.
I recently dined at "The Garfish" on Saturday for lunch. It was my girlfriend's birthday and we ordered the "fruit de Mer" platter. I had chosen this restaurant on account of my previous dining experience there; The food was great, a lovely spot overlooking the water and informative friendly service.
I was a little disappointed with the presentation of the platter. Perhaps I expected a more elaborate display of food, maybe some fruit. Most seafood platters typically come with fruit, and are quite generously laid out.
Whilst I enjoyed the wood fired crustaceans, I thought there may have been a few more. When you consider most platters contain lobster, and this didn't i felt like there could have been at least 2 scampi and 2 prawns each; On ours we had 3 scampi and 3 prawns to split up an odd number. There were 4 half portions of bugs fortunately. I thought that for the price of the platter, and the absence of lobster we may have seen a more generous serving of crustaceans.
I suppose I was left thinking of my first experience, where we ordered an entree and main, and how great those dishes were. I had 6 half bugs then, and a lovely piece of fish and salad. I felt like the platter wasn't special for a typical platter and that short cuts had been taken to put it together.
I also felt like the array of sauces accompanying the Crustaceans were limited with only 1 creamy dipping sauce.
It actually felt like all the food was CRAMMED onto a rather petite plate, and thought not considered for the presentation.
The scallops were so sweet, but there was no condiment to accompany them. I expected perhaps some cauliflower or brandy sauce or something to go with them. Like I believe the traditional entree of scallops receives.
It just felt like that we got the raw-deal because we didn't choose the typical entrees and mains; whereas in my opinion the platter should have been the SHOWCASE, the penultimate gathering of their best food.
The day was glorious, the views outstanding and the our seats were just about the best in the restaurant closest to the window, or lack of window, with best views to the ocean.
I felt the service was humble, and a good attempt was made, but lacked the experience and professionalism of the waiter we had the previous time we dined. It appeared like our waiter was new to the job, but I felt like we didn't receive the information of the food that was brought out. It was like here it is, there's the food, enjoy... but what sauces are they?
The opening course to the platter was nicely presented with 3 sauces, and a lovely vinegarette, which worked well with the oysters.
I felt like the small leafy salad we received as a side with the platter was poor, lifeless and sparse. It needed a lift with some other vegetables.
Visually the platter in general wasn't well constructed.
The mains and entrees in general actually stand out at you and are very inviting, as if to say, come eat me. The platter just looked derived. I was hoping for more BLING on such a special occasion.
I went away thinking, we were better off choosing 1 entree and 1 main each, and we would have enjoyed much better food and it served much visually inviting.
The garlic wood fired bread was the standout of the whole meal; it was very tasty.
I am destined to return, but not for the platter. I still feel a bit hardly done by. I have experience much better platters at several other restaurants. If I returned I would be getting the Moreton Bay bugs as an entree and a beautiful piece of fish for the main...
Thats another slightly disappointing part of the platter; there was no fish. most platters service a nice fillet of fish or something stand-out.
This restaurant has one of the best locations, and it is capable of producing fantastic meals which are visually tempting, but they let me down with the platter. I would not recommend the platter to anyone sadly, and I wished that was not the case. I feel like "The Garfish" has and can do better with their platter.
The waitress I had the first time around, was so informative, on the ball, professional and always a step ahead, providing us with professional customer service in a friendly and non-confronting manner; I wish I remembered her name.
I thought our waiter this time tried hard. It took a while for my wine to come back out once the bread entree arrived, but he did tend to my empty glass quite well, and gave us extra clean napkins half way through the platter. I thought that was thoughtful!
I thought a stunning day, with acceptable food and service, but nothing too special, which was a shame.
The banana brulee was well enjoyed by my partner.
On the first encounter, I gave the food an solid 8, and the service a solid 9. This time around I have to give the food and service a satisfactory 6. I felt the value was closer to an 8 the first time but this time it was a dismal 5.
Quite contrasting experiences, with a goldmine establishment and great potential to really show off some great seafood.